Cleveland Thermal Energy

District Heating in the City

Cleveland's extensive network of underground pipes supply steam heat and chilled water to make several downtown facilities comfortable in all seasons.

District heating and cooling denotes the network of delivery of thermal energy to a group of proximate buildings or structures from a central source. The concept was first recorded with the use of Roman hypocausts, a hot air furnace, designed to warm a close group of buildings. The design evolved during the Renaissance to tap hot springs’ heat and energy to channel warmth to nearby buildings, inspiring further architectural development to incorporate thermal energy into urban development. By the 17th century, several countries in Europe, England, and Scandinavia relied upon hot water and steam to centrally heat neighboring buildings, both factories and residences. The efficiency of these systems attracted awareness across the Atlantic, and as technology evolved during the 19th century the Exhibition of 1851 marked the heating of several exhibits including the Crystal Palace via a separate boiler. During the next 25 years, European and American cities, including London, New York, Philadelphia, and Springfield, Illinois, boasted district heating. Later in the century, the cooling of structures was added to the district energy distribution concept. More cities throughout the United States incorporated heating and cooling systems into urban developments.

District heating in Cleveland evolved as part of the pioneering electric generation industry spawned by Charles Brush’s street lamps on the city’s Public Square. During the 1890s Brush Electric joined Cleveland Electric light to form General Electric Light Company which evolved into Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company by 1894 to respond to the increasing demand for electric service throughout the city. Between 1895 and 1906, the design and development of CEI’s Canal Road generation plant attracted worldwide attention via the advanced engineering used to generate electricity and steam at the site. Located on the east bank of the Cuyahoga River, clean water access was available but not ideal as upstream mills and factories polluted the resource as CEI looked to develop the byproduct of coal-fired electricity generation into a district heating business. By 1910, the Canal Road plant switched to city water to generate steam and expand its reach into the downtown area.

During the second decade of the 20th century, CEI continued to respond to the demand for increased regional electric and local steam power with progress on the infrastructure to deliver the energy. Competition for customers also grew during this period. Other local steam plants arose to supply power to proximate factories and institutions as the area developed. Among these competitors were Bradley, Cleveland, and Cuyahoga Light and Power Companies.

A new generation plant was built at East 20th Street and Hamilton Avenue in 1924 to complement Canal Road production of both electricity and steam. The Canal Road plant was re-engineered, demolished, and rebuilt in 1928. Over the next twenty years CEI expanded its steam business to serve more than 660 customers bounded by Prospect Avenue north to Lake Erie and the Cuyahoga River east to East 24th Street. CEI continued to be recognized as a leader in the district heating technology and business, setting a national example. In 1946, the Canal Road plant ceased electric power production and turned to steam only. Two years later, CEI constructed three 235-foot colossal smokestacks at the Canal Road plant to provide greater draft for new boilers at the plant. The stacks were 12 feet inside diameter and 13 feet outside diameter steel and brick construction. During construction, workers ascended and descended the inside of the stacks while standing on a crane ball. The three tall stacks replaced ten smaller stacks and became a ‘landmark’ sight along Ontario Avenue visible from Public Square looking south. Only one remains today.

CEI continued to operate the steam generation and heating business throughout the next four decades amid legal and political disputes during an era of deregulation of public utilities, fierce competition with Cleveland Public Power (the city owned power company serving local customers), and corporate mergers and acquisitions. In 1982, several steam buildings left CEI for cheaper heat from natural gas sources. By the mid 1980s, Cuyahoga County's downtown facilities were CEI’s number one steam customer and Cleveland State University was second among downtown customers. One notable eight-year dispute between Cleveland State University and CEI over rates was ultimately settled in 1987 when CEI sold both plants and the steam operation to Youngstown’s Catalyst Thermal to operate as Cleveland Thermal Energy Corporation (CleTEC).

CleTEC operated the steam heating and expanded chilling operations for the next 28 years. During that time, corporate control of CleTEC changed hands twice until it was bought by the Canadian firm Corix in 2015. Corix moved to phase out the less eficient Canal Road plant in favor of the upgraded Hamilton Avenue plant with high-efficiency steam production using clean-burning natural gas. The Canal Road Plant closed in 2017.

Today, "Cleveland Thermal’s pipeline spans more than 30 million square feet throughout the Downtown Cleveland footprint. This pipeline delivers district steam and chilled water 24 hours a day, 365 days a year to downtown customers."

Images

"A Giant Trio of New Stacks" This 1948 photo, taken looking north from the Lorain-Carnegie Bridge, shows three new smokestacks under construction at the Canal Road power plant. Stacks to the left would be removed. Source: Cleveland Public Library Date: September 12, 1948
Remains of the Canal Road Power Plant, 2021 Serving steam from 1903 until 2016. The Canal Road plant is now quiet. A single smokestack survives. Creator: Jim Lanese Date: October, 2021
Canal Road Steam Plant Cleveland Electric & Illuminating Co. Canal Road steam plant along the west approach to the Cleveland Union Terminal. Source: Cleveland State University Library Special Collections
Aerial View of the Canal Road Power Plant A southward view over the "Forest City" depicts the blend of smokestack power serving a tree-laden city. The power plant provided regional electricity and downtown steam heat to Cleveland. Source: Cleveland State University Library Special Collections Date: October 1949
Canal Road Power Plant Looking East-Northeast This aerial view illustrates the direction of CEI steam heat distribution east to the Innerbelt and north to Lake Erie into the downtown buildings. Source: Cleveland State University Library Special Collections Date: ca. 1950
Low Sulphur Coal Conversion CEI converted the Canal Road plant to burn low sulphur coal to produce steam in the 1970s in response to environmental initiatives. Source: Cleveland Puiblic Library Date: September, 1976
The Canal Road Plant, 2021 The Canal Road Power plant served up steam for 113 years. It ceased operations in 2016 yielding to the upgraded Hamilton plant. Creator: Jim Lanese Date: October 2021
One Landmark Yet Stands Emerging southbound on Ontario Street from Public Square, a single remaining smokestack of the Canal Road plant dominates the view. The east end piers of the Hope Memorial Bridge are visible in the lower right corner of this photograph. Creator: Jim Lanese Date: October 2021
Hydrobin Storage Coal ash is piped into a hydrobin at the Canal Road plant for storage until it is trucked away for disposal. Source: Cleveland Public Library Date: September 1976
Switchyard of the Hamilton - East 20th Street Steam Plant In 1971, CEI converted from coal to low-sulphur oil to produce steam for customers. Source: Cleveand Public Library Date: September 1976
Smokestack Repair, Hamilton Avenue Plant Source: Cleveland State University Library Special Collections Date: July 1963
Hamilton-East 20th Street Power Plant The Hamilton plant evolved as the single source of steam heat and chilled Water for Cleveland's heating and air conditioning needs in Cleveland Thermal's second century of service. Creator: Jim Lanese Date: October 2021

Documents

NameInfoActions
Cleveland Thermal System Map, 2021pdf / 1.20 MBDownload

Location

1921 Hamilton Ave, Cleveland, OH 44114

Metadata

Jim Lanese, “Cleveland Thermal Energy,” Cleveland Historical, accessed May 23, 2022, https://clevelandhistorical.org/index.php/items/show/953.