Gordon Square: From Outlaw Enclave to Arts District

10 Locations | Curated by Cleveland Historical

The Gordon Square Arts District comprises an area of the west side of Cleveland which was once most famously known as the home grounds of the McCart Street gang, one of Cleveland's most infamous street gangs.

During the gang's late nineteenth century reign, and thereafter well into the twentieth century, the neighborhood experienced successive waves of immigration from Europe, which marked it in unique and special ways. Today, in the space of a short walk, visitors can experience the Irish, the Italians, the Romanians, and others who contributed to making this one of the most interesting historic ethnic neighborhoods of Cleveland.

From West Cleveland Village and headquarters of the notorious McCart Street Gang in the late nineteenth century to the late twentieth century arrival of Cleveland Public Theater (CPT) and rebirth of Gordon Square Arcade and the Capitol Theater, this west side neighborhood of Cleveland has, over the course of the last 130 years, successfully transitioned into a vibrant arts district which has managed to retain a unique ethnic neighborhood flavor.

Carved out of the Brooklyn Township territory, West Cleveland was incorporated as a village in 1871. The new suburb consisted of 1,500 acres of land and was bounded on the north by Lake Erie, on the east by the Cleveland corporation line near Gordon Avenue (West 65th Street), on the west by…
View Story | Show on Map

The Zitiello Bank, located at 6810 Herman Avenue, was the earliest known ethnic bank opened in the Detroit-Shoreway neighborhood. The bank was founded by Joseph Zitiello, an immigrant from the Campania region of Italy who came to Cleveland in 1898. Joseph was just one of several members of the…
View Story | Show on Map

Upon entering Cleveland's west side "Little Italy", one is instantly met with a display of Italian colors on benches, fire hydrants, sidewalks, and telephone poles. Best known for its street processionals and annual church festival, this small Italian neighborhood dates back to the…
View Story | Show on Map

A Romanian settlement grew and flourished along Detroit Avenue between West 45th Street and West 65th Street from the 1900s to the middle of the century. The self-contained neighborhood housed a variety of businesses both owned by and catering to the needs of the surrounding ethnic neighborhood. …
View Story | Show on Map

Founded in 1904, St. Mary's Romanian Orthodox Church was the first Romanian Orthodox parish established in the United States. Originally located on Detroit Avenue, the parish's development and eventual relocation to Warren Road parallels the story of the Romanian immigrant experience in…
View Story | Show on Map

Located on West 65th Street near Detroit Avenue, St. Helena Romanian Catholic Church marks the site of Cleveland's largest Romanian enclave during the early 20th century. St. Helena's was built under the guidance of Father Epaminonda S. Lucaci, the first Romanian priest to serve in the…
View Story | Show on Map

The Gordon Square Arcade opened to the public on April 8, 1921. The unique and massive structure quickly became the centerpiece of the Gordon Square commercial district, and a source of pride for the surrounding neighborhood. The monumental building was not only constructed to meet the needs of the…
View Story | Show on Map

On April 8, 1921, the Capitol Theatre opened its doors to the public at the dedication of the Gordon Square Arcade and Community Building. Developed by the West Side Amusement Co. and Canadian motion picture theater promoters Jule and J.J. Allen, the theater began as a vaudeville and silent film…
View Story | Show on Map

Cleveland Public Theatre was founded in 1982 by Cleveland native James Levin. From its early years, CPT was instrumental in promoting, creating, and providing a home for experimental theater in the Cleveland area. Initially sparking interest in local theater through productions such as…
View Story | Show on Map

Show Comments